John W. Carlin and Civic Leadership
Join the Conversation:
  • Home
  • About John
  • Blog
  • Leading and Learning Moments
  • Leader Corner
  • Resources
    • Feedback

A Unique Opportunity for Speaker Boehner

9/29/2015

1 Comment

 
​Anybody who follows the news, particularly national news, last week had a field day. For me, it was the combination of the visit of Pope Francis, all of the analysis of what his remarks before Congress on Thursday meant, the Friday morning resignation of Speaker of the House John Boehner, and the Speaker’s comments over the weekend (see the video clip below). The combination has the potential to make some history. It will be up to the Speaker whether that is the case.

The current practice is: nothing gets passed in the House unless it is with the majority of votes needed, all coming from the Republican Caucus. That means anytime the far-right wing of the party, a group of 30 to 40, oppose something, the vote is never taken. For in many cases, if it was, there would be more than enough Democrats who would go along to pass it. That is what has held up many important pieces of legislation that have had the votes in the Senate but died in the House.

With the scheduled resignation of the Speaker for late October, he has an option that he has not been willing to play up to this point. For the sake of the country, his legacy, and the broader image of the Republican Party, he could simply allow key legislation to come up and let the Democrats provide the votes necessary to make them pass. With what appears to be the positive influence of the Pope’s visit on the Speaker, it could happen and certainly should. 

What makes this personally interesting is that it is similar to one of the challenges I had when I was Speaker of the House in Kansas. Out of the 1976 election, Democrats achieved a majority in the Kansas House for only the second time in Kansas history, with 65 Democrats and 60 Republicans. To pass any legislation, it would require no less than 63 votes, meaning if there was no Republican support, I could lose only two Democratic votes to be successful. The difference from today in Washington is that, back then, the pressure to get basically all Democrats on board only occurred on new initiatives that we Democrats were pushing. The bulk of the daily agenda, including all budget issues, were debated and voted on without strict party control. 

In Washington now for some time, that pressure to unify the party in power has been on almost everything. This means that if the Speaker couldn’t pass it with only Republicans, he didn’t bring it up, giving huge power to a very small minority—a minority that the Speaker (as you’ll see in the video clip below) clearly labeled as unrealistic in the their approaches. The result has been stalled progress on a number of key issues of importance to the American people. Now Speaker Boehner has a small window to make tangible steps to improve the country, but will he seize the moment?
View More: Live News|More News Videos
1 Comment
Richard Claypoole
9/30/2015 04:20:07 pm

Governor Carlin is certainly right about the opportunity for legislative achievement if Speaker Boehner abandons the "Hastert Rule" and allows bills to be considered that don't reach the 218 vote threshold solely through the Republican majority. Boehner would be showing the statesmanship that escaped the Democrats under Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid who used the rules of their chambers to choke off any minority amendments to legislation, a vote on which might threaten their members reelection chances. But somebody has to act the grown-up and Speaker Boehner has seized the opportunity. As a conservative who believes in actually governing, not grandstanding, I hope Boehner is able to push through more than the temporary Government funding measure. The borrowing limit has to be raised, tax breaks need to be extended, and the long-delayed, job-creating transportation bill is a legislative must. I'm only sorry that a much needed overhaul of the tax system is probably a bridge too far at this late date as well as something that Senate democrats would squash through their anti-democratic use of cloture. If only Harry Reid were leading the republicans, rules would be changed in a heartbeat and real, needed reform of the tax code could finally be passed. Remember Obama Care passing only because Reid brought it to a vote through the "reconciliation" procedure. And before we lose too much touch with political reality, even if tax reform did pass, it most certainly would face Obama's veto pen. So, yes, lets hope a new day is upon us. If the pope believes that religious freedom will be protected" as a matter of conscience" and that life will be protected "in all stages of its development", then I can believe that both parties can act to serve the nation and not just themselves.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    John W. Carlin​—​61st Speaker of the Kansas House, 40th Governor of Kansas, 8th Archivist of the United States, and student of leadership

    Categories

    All
    Agriculture
    Budgets And Taxation
    Capital Punishment
    China
    Civic Engagement
    Drinking Age
    Education
    Election 2016
    Election 2018
    Election 2020
    Election 2022
    Election 2024
    Environment
    Health Care
    Higher Education
    Historical Perspective
    Infrastructure
    Judicial System
    Leadership
    LGBTQ Rights
    National Archives
    Research
    Teaching

    Facebook

    John W. Carlin

    Twitter

    Tweets by @johnwcarlin

    Subscribe

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed