John W. Carlin and Civic Leadership
Join the Conversation:
  • Home
  • About John
  • Blog
  • Leading and Learning Moments
  • Leader Corner
  • Resources
    • Feedback

DeVos and Public Education are Like Oil and Water

2/1/2017

7 Comments

 
Public education is critical to our democracy, but there is no real evidence that Betsy DeVos has any commitment to its mission of education and equal opportunity for all students.

Mr. President, why appoint a 100% private education advocate to run the Department of Education? I know the Cabinet at large was looking too white and too male, but surely you could have found someone who thinks public education is important today and in our future. Whether competent or not, it would at least look better.

To our Senators from Kansas, one of whom has already approved her for confirmation in a committee vote, a reminder that Kansans of all political stripes support public education. If you vote for her on the floor of the Senate, which is a choice you have, don’t ever come back to Kansas and say you support public education, because you don’t.

Kansas school districts have unique challenges, and federal support can play a role in addressing them. Yes, most of the responsibility for public schools is with the states and local school districts, as it should be. But there are key areas where the input and resources can make a difference, like with the Junction City school system for example where the presence of Fort Riley brings additional challenges. The same goes for our rural school districts as well. Also, because education is so critical to our nation’s future, it makes total sense that there be a national leadership role, not just monitoring but helping lead reform measures to improve the system nationwide.

Ms. DeVos is as pure a private education advocate as one could find anywhere in the United States. Her only experience at any level is with private schools. In addition, she is a strong supporter of having guns in our schools, and when asked for her reasoning, she said you never know when a grizzly bear might show up in the classroom. Well, I’d encourage her to listen to what teachers have to say on this issue and many others. I have a feeling most would agree that DeVos herself poses a much greater threat to our schools than grizzly bear attacks do.

What I suspect, and fear, is that this is just the first move toward abolishing the Department of Education. If she’s confirmed, it will not surprise me at all if Ms. DeVos finds all sorts of “problems” with the Department and “reluctantly” comes to the President recommending it be shut down. The future of “education for all” is directly at stake in this upcoming vote. Every Senate Democrat and two Republicans have already agreed to vote “no.” Will there be others who join them to stand up for public education?

The number to the Congressional Switchboard is (202) 225-3121. Your engagement could make the difference.
7 Comments
Donna Viola
2/1/2017 05:02:57 pm

I received a KNEA alert just a while ago and made another request to Sen Moran to vote NO for Betsy DeVos as Education Sec. Last night and this morning, I contacted all Republican Senators to request, strongly, they vote NO. Several contacts have been made to Sen Roberts (who voted FOR DeVos in committee) and Sen Moran. As a KNEA member, veteran teacher, mother of two fine daughters who went through public school and now a grandmother to my 4 year old who is in PUBLIC preschool, this just makes me crazy and plain heart sick! Prayers are being said and fingers (and toes!) are crossed! Thank you for your insightful, interesting blog.

Reply
Norma Oborg
2/1/2017 05:04:23 pm

Ms DeVos would be a complete disaster for public education, not only in Kansas but throughout the U.S.!! She has never been involved with public schools and I implore our congressmen to re-evaluate their thinking on this very important issue for public schools. Please listen to our educators. I have always been proud of the public schools in Kansas and we cannot afford to go backwards in teaching the boys and girls in the State of Kansas. This is not just a Kansas issue but should be a real concern for parents throughout the U.S. Pay attention parents!

Reply
Sharon Texley
2/2/2017 05:57:05 am

Well said, John. I've been trying to call Senator Flake of Arizona (202-224-4521) as a possible third Republican "No" vote. So far his mailbox is full, but I'll keep trying.

Reply
Dennis link
2/2/2017 01:32:36 pm

I ran for KS Senate Dist. 20 last year based entirely on this one issue. I am a Teacher and Native American Edu-cultural Specialist. As Founder/Director of Native American Studies Programs I've presented school assemblies ALL across the USA and Abroad. I KNOW EDUCATION. Sadly, I am more qualified to provide Leadership to the appointment than Ms. Voes. Her lack of knowledge or leadership in this appointed position can and will lead AMERICA down a very dangerous road.

Reply
Jan Turner
2/2/2017 01:43:49 pm

Please do not vote for Betsy DeVoe to lead the Department of Education. She can't even answer questions that she should know about public education. She is not a good choice

Reply
Joan Warren
2/2/2017 10:29:54 pm

I went to Senator Moran's office in Wichita and talked to his
representative. 3450 N Rock Road, bldg 200. Go in person if you can. The other offices are on Moran's website. Thanks Gov. Carlin. YOU ROCK.

Reply
kenneth D. Randall link
2/6/2017 12:23:23 pm

I am opposed to this nominee because she does not have any record of service in the public schools. I believe that students who are sensory impaired (Deaf and Blind) will not receive the specialized equipment and interpreters. The social experiment of "mainstreaming' has not been successful. Results of 94-142 are more relevant to the decline in the number of births in this country.This nominee does not have a record of service in achieving the rights of students to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness as guaranted by the Constitution of this country.



that

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    John W. Carlin​—​61st Speaker of the Kansas House, 40th Governor of Kansas, 8th Archivist of the United States, and student of leadership

    Categories

    All
    Agriculture
    Budgets And Taxation
    Capital Punishment
    China
    Civic Engagement
    Drinking Age
    Education
    Election 2016
    Election 2018
    Election 2020
    Election 2022
    Election 2024
    Environment
    Health Care
    Higher Education
    Historical Perspective
    Infrastructure
    Judicial System
    Leadership
    LGBTQ Rights
    National Archives
    Research
    Teaching

    Facebook

    John W. Carlin

    Twitter

    Tweets by @johnwcarlin

    Subscribe

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed