John W. Carlin and Civic Leadership
Join the Conversation:
  • Home
  • About John
  • Blog
  • Leading and Learning Moments
  • Leader Corner
  • Resources
    • Feedback

Republican Presidential Debate: December 15th

12/16/2015

2 Comments

 
If you are wondering why I follow the Republican debates when you might assume my focus would only be with the Democrats, here is why. One, I can always learn something of value both from a tactical point of view as well as an idea that just makes good sense. But most important, I do want the Republican nominee to be someone who would possibly do a good job. I am first an American, and my candidate might lose, so I want as much as possible for that eventual nominee  to be positive for the country. Taking the self-serving position of wanting the Republican nominee to be the easiest to defeat runs too much risk of not being the way it works out in the end.

Now as to last night, here is the way I saw it. Going into the debate, Trump’s outrageous comments on Muslims—​totally void of any understanding of how much he was further complicating the fight against ISIL—​seemed to only bolster his support. The assumption was that more reasonable candidates would take him on. But, in the end, only Governor Jeb Bush made it his focus and maybe helping his own cause but I doubt, for now, hurting the Donald. Senator Cruz backed away from any fight with Trump and instead took on Senator Rubio. What will be interesting is whether the comments from the candidates with executive experience, making it clear that Senate experience is often more about talk and banter, will have an impact going forward. 
​

And consistent with earlier debates, there were no direct questions pushing the candidates to explain how they were going to actually get something done, like who would be their foreign policy advisers for example. This allowed most of the candidates to focus on shots at the current administration and pushing their rhetoric with the hope that their lack of executive experience would be passed over. Fortunately, Governors Kasich and Christie took the initiative to not just push their experience but linked it to getting the job actually done. I was particularly impressed with Kasich for making it clear that working across the aisle and being willing to compromise would be essential to getting anything actually done.
2 Comments
Tom Holmquist
12/16/2015 04:51:54 pm

I watched the debate last night and thought Kasich and Bush both made the most logical sense. I was extremely dismayed at the after debate spin session where Trump, when asked whether he would choose security over the 1st Amendment, chose security. Many voters support him and his rhetoric. This is not 1931 Germany. We must not succumb to fear and demagoguery.

Reply
Elizabeth
12/16/2015 06:16:22 pm

Even though my opinions tend toward the Democrat platforms (except in the case of abortion policies), I have always registered in Kansas as a Republican so I can vote in the primaries for the exact reason you mention: just in case the Republican wins, I want it to be the best of the bunch. I almost always vote a mixed ballot, especially in local elections. In the last few years, however, I just hold my nose and vote for the least objectionable candidates. I like your distinction between agreeing with a candidate on an issue and that person's ability to do anything about it.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    John W. Carlin​—​61st Speaker of the Kansas House, 40th Governor of Kansas, 8th Archivist of the United States, and student of leadership

    Categories

    All
    Agriculture
    Budgets And Taxation
    Capital Punishment
    China
    Civic Engagement
    Drinking Age
    Education
    Election 2016
    Election 2018
    Election 2020
    Election 2022
    Election 2024
    Environment
    Health Care
    Higher Education
    Historical Perspective
    Infrastructure
    Judicial System
    Leadership
    LGBTQ Rights
    National Archives
    Research
    Teaching

    Facebook

    John W. Carlin

    Twitter

    Tweets by @johnwcarlin

    Subscribe

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed