John W. Carlin and Civic Leadership
Join the Conversation:
  • Home
  • About John
  • Blog
  • Leader Exchange
  • Leading and Learning Moments
  • Leader Corner
  • Resources
    • Feedback

To Stay In or Leave Kansas?

10/11/2016

10 Comments

 
Matt Lindsey
​This past summer, the Board of Regents noted a disturbing trend. Fewer and fewer graduates of Kansas’ colleges and universities are choosing to stay here. Nearly half of those earning a bachelor’s degree are leaving the state within five years. It’s a starker picture for graduate degrees. 45 percent of master’s degree recipients and 67 percent of doctoral degree recipients leave within one year of graduation.
 
For young professionals, the choice of staying in Kansas (or moving to Kansas) is driven by the answers to the questions that my wife and I discuss nightly. And study after study shows that a state’s economy and the health of our communities bears a close correlation to the migration patterns of these professionals. If they stay (and more come), our state’s future is bright. If they leave, a downward spiral is difficult to escape.
 
After putting our young daughter to bed each night, my wife and I have been having nearly the same conversation for more than a year now. The details of our discussion might vary night to night, but at the core, the principal questions are the same. And I believe, from talking to friends, family, neighbors, and co-workers, that a similar conversation goes on in many houses across Kansas each evening. I believe these conversations are happening among college graduates too.
 
The central questions are these:

  • Is the state of Kansas going to be able to recover from the enormous set of challenges that have been created by disastrous policy-making in Topeka over the past six years?
  • When our children are old enough to attend public school, will we still have high-performing schools filled with teachers who—while still not paid nearly what their commitment and service is worth—feel valued and are encouraged to be innovative? Or we continue to see our elected officials pinch pennies and play shell games with school finances as a means to justify other agendas?
  • Will our local officials continue to be placed in a heavy straightjacket by state leaders, preventing cities and towns from addressing local infrastructure and social needs like libraries, parks, transit, and public safety? Because of those damaging limits, will our home increase in value in parallel with a healthy, thriving, community? Or will the mythology of the primacy of low business taxes crowd out our abilities to make our neighborhoods better?
  • Are our retired, public teacher parents, going to have the retirement income that they paid for? Or do we need to plan for the day when KPERS is no longer solvent at all because our elected leaders “borrowed” from their share until it was gone?
 
These questions—and the answers—matter deeply to us. And I know they matter deeply to thousands of others like us.
​
Kansas used to be a place of pragmatism, bipartisanship, and moderation. These past six years have instead been times of blind ideology, faith in discredited economic theory, and efforts to create a terrifying dystopia where there are guns nearly everywhere, affordable health care options nearly nowhere, and proudly mean-spirited attempts to have the government define boundaries on the right of each of us to make a life with someone we love. And because of that dark turn, many have turned away from Kansas, putting our future at even greater risk.
 
Moreover, we must remember this. Many like me—and young professionals and college graduates who are weighing whether to stay or to leave—are privileged to be able to do so. But many Kansans who are being hurt by the direction our state has taken do not have the luxury of this same choice. For some, their economic prospects, whether due to poverty or profession, do not allow them to easily leave Kansas even as the state makes their lives harder. For others, the demands of family, whether it be attending to parents or grandparents in decline, or medical conditions of a spouse or children, are likewise constrained from choosing freely. They are all forced to endure whatever Kansas throws at them.
 
That’s why the answers to these questions matter. It matters because we have to stop digging and start rebuilding. It matters because we need to elect leaders who want to make Kansas a place everyone sees as a beacon of practicality and commitment to community. 
 
Next month, it is essential that we all take steps to turn the ship of state around. I hope everyone reading this votes. I hope everyone reading this finds one more person to encourage to vote, one person they can drive to the polls, one person they can call to remind to vote. We need to elect leaders who are focused first and foremost on getting our state’s fiscal affairs in order, and then on returning to pragmatic approaches to how to meet the purposes of government—to ensure each and every Kansan has the ability to live safe, educated, and healthy.

​Matt Lindsey is the president of the Kansas Independent College Association & Fund, where he coordinates a range of programs designed to strengthen Kansas' private, non-profit, colleges through collaboration, governmental advocacy, and public engagement and to support the ability of college students to choose and afford an effective, high-quality college education that fits their individual goals. Lindsey previously worked as the Executive Director for Kansas Campus Compact and as an adjunct faculty member with Kansas State University's Staley School of Leadership Studies. He also worked in Washington, DC as the Senior Associate for Freedman Consulting, where he advised non-profits, philanthropies, and civic groups on public advocacy strategies.

10 Comments
Walter Lindsey
10/11/2016 09:23:22 pm

You have perfectly summed up our problem in Kansas. We all need to take these points to heart and do our part to solve these problems. We need to start by voting for candidates that share the values you have listed very concisely. Thank you.

Reply
Mark
10/11/2016 10:12:33 pm

Voting is necessary, but so is systemic change that ends our current system of legalized bribery. Money is not speech. Corporations are not people. We need a constitutional amendment to make this happen.

Reply
Nick
10/12/2016 08:58:28 am

We have the same conversations at our house, and like you, it's almost every night. With two young children who will be entering the school system soon, we're constantly worried what all the budget shortfalls will mean for the quality of their education.

As business owners ourselves, we would much rather pay our fair share of taxes and have that money fund the services the state needs to take care of its people, especially its students. Saving a few thousand dollars each year isn't worth the detriment the legislature's tax policies are causing the state.

Thanks for so clearly illuminating the problems that are lurking ahead. Hopefully our electorate takes note and votes accordingly.

Reply
Debra
10/12/2016 09:51:41 am

You made excellent, insightful points for all to consider. I am thinking how many of these same issues apply in states all over the U.S. We need to get out and vote...but just as important as getting out and voting, we need candidates we can vote for, who shine with integrity, wisdom, and true compassion for equality, with the passion for change that benefits all. Thank you for your informative article.

Reply
Barb
10/12/2016 11:54:37 am

Very thoughtful & eloquent essay. I have struggled with the same questions, & that is why I am retiring as a K State professor & leaving Kansas.

Reply
Florence Lynch
10/12/2016 01:26:24 pm

Just as fewer college graduates are choosing to stay in KC we in Me are faced with the same issues. This is also due to the poor economy, lack of good jobs available. Seems like teachers are underpaid everywhere for all the services they offer. Not only are teachers concerned about their retirement income but it seems their is also a concern about whether or not SSI benefits will be affected. Will there be money in that Ins account for the next generation? Not only is it important to vote, but also to listen & hear what each candidate has to say , their promises & commitment to all.

Reply
Becky Borton
10/12/2016 02:38:45 pm

While I am older and do not have children, I am wrestling with the same issues. When I moved to KS about 10 years ago, the state was well-run, had good schools, and political discourse was healthy, and moderate. Now, the state is horribly in debt, school funding is taking a hit, the politics has taken an ugly extremist right turn, and oh, yeah, I am paying a high rate in sales tax on food! What happened? Brownback, Kobach, and extremists in the legislature have destroyed our credit rating, downgraded our schools and our reputation for fairness and justice. Why stay in a third-world state? I can go elsewhere, pay less in taxes, have schools that are funded and don't have to worry that my voter registration has mysteriously been dropped from the rolls.

I don't envy the author as to the decision his family will have to make to stay or go. Do what you have to do. Let's hope the good people of Kansas in November are finally outraged to the point of saying, "Enough!"

Reply
Andrew J Von Lintel
10/12/2016 07:08:28 pm

Economics and jobs certainly matter to the health and future of any City, State, or Country. Unfortunately, Kansas has

Reply
Andrew J VonLintel
10/12/2016 07:11:45 pm

Unfortunately Kansas has been declining as a % of the U.S. population since the 1890 census. Jobs and the economy are the most important factors. Jobs have generally went south to more capitalistic states like Texas.

Reply
Pamela Adams link
10/12/2016 09:12:05 pm

It is refreshing to see that everyone who has commented has supported your view. I am a recently retired teacher who graduated from Bethany College in 1981. I knew many years before that I wanted to teach and make a difference in the lives of children. I really wanted to work many more years but gave into the fact that I was not valued as a seasoned educator who refused to bend to the status quo. I only hope that what I paid into KPERS will continue to be there for me as I continue to age. I grieve for our nation, our state, and our children as we go through this process of electing a new president, new senators, and new congressmen. I pray that the lord will guide each and every one of us to make well thought out decisions.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Featured Author

    Richard L. Claypoole served in a variety of leadership positions for the National Archives, including being the Director of the Office of the Federal Register and the Assistant Archivist for Presidential Libraries and Museums. 

    ​He was an editor of the Public Papers of Gerald Ford and Jimmy Carter and editor in chief of the Public Papers of Ronald Reagan.

    Contributors

    All
    Jackie Vietti
    Jill Docking
    Joe Harkins
    Kristine Polansky
    Matt Lindsey
    Max Hale
    Rich Claypoole
    Sandy Praeger
    Theo Stavropoulos

    Facebook

    John W. Carlin

    Twitter

    Tweets by @johnwcarlin